Differentiation Paradox

If we write x*x as x+...+x (x times), then we will see;

x*x=x+...+x
Deriving both sides;
2x=1+...+1
Summing the right hand side back;
2x=x
This is true for all x, in particular for x=1
2=1

This causes somewhat of discomfort in mathematicians' hearts. Could you relieve them by pointing out what's wrong? Hint: x is not 0. We did not limit it at any point.

Solution

Password:
Back to Index